Start with your reason
Grading can serve different purposes: authentication, standardized condition, protection, resale liquidity, registry collecting, or simply presentation. A card does not need to be financially optimal to be worth grading for a personal collection.
But if the goal is resale, the economics matter.
Estimate the realistic grade range
Inspect centering, corners, edges, and especially Chrome surfaces. Do not make the decision using only the best-case grade.
Compare raw copies and several graded outcomes. A card that only makes sense at a perfect grade may not be a good grading candidate.
Add every cost
Include grading fee, shipping both ways, insurance or declared value fees where applicable, supplies, and the time your card is out of your possession.
The difference between raw and graded market value needs to exceed more than the headline grading fee if profit is the goal.
Scarcity does not guarantee a premium
A /5 or 1/1 may be valuable raw because scarcity is already obvious. Some collectors prefer rare cards unslabbed, while others value authentication and protection. The decision depends on the specific card and buyer pool.
For autograph or sketch cards, originality and eye appeal may matter as much as a numerical grade.
Use a simple decision test
Ask four questions: Do I trust the card's condition? Is authentication valuable? Does a slab improve how I want to own or sell it? Does the cost make sense relative to the card? If several answers are no, grading can wait.
Connected archive